Skip to main content

Table 1 Volatile species detected by EGA-GC–MS for 16 plastic materials used in museums. Also included are the predicted Oddy test result based on the volatiles detected and the actual Oddy test result from triplicate experiments

From: Relating volatiles analysis by GC–MS to Oddy test performance for determining the suitability of museum construction materials

Material

Composition

VOC profile by EGA at 115 °C

Comments and justification

Predicted Oddy result

Actual Oddy result

Agateen

Cellulose nitrate

Acetic acid a

n-Butyl acetate

Other solvents

Acetic acid is known to corrode lead coupons [1]. This acid is likely to have been formed from hydrolysis of the residual n-butyl acetate solvent

F

Fb

Delrin

Poly(oxymethylene), POM

Formaldehyde a

Phthalate plasticizer

Formaldehyde is a known pollutant. The resulting formic acid can corrode metal, cause brittleness in cellulose films, and attack calcium rich objects [1]

F

F

Cellulose propionate window gel

Cellulose propionate

Propionic acid a

tris(1-Chloro-2-propyl) phosphate

Organic acids are known to be corrosive [1]

This phosphate fire retardant may undergo hydrolysis and form phosphoric acid, which can corrode metal objects [1, 30]

F

F

ULINE adhesive, economy

Ethylene/vinyl acetate copolymer, EVA

Acetic acid a

Branched hydrocarbons

Tetradecanoic acid

Hexadecanoic acid

Organic acids are predicted to corrode the lead coupon [1]

F

F/T

ULINE adhesive, heavy duty

Polyethylene/olefin

Carbonyl sulfide a

Sulfur dioxide a

Dibutylamine

Dibutylformamide

Butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT)

Hexadecanoic acid

Organic amines are known to cause corrosion of bronze, copper, and silver [28]

F

F/T

RTV162 silicone sealant

Silicone

Dipropylene glycol monomethyl ether

Siloxanes

 

P

F

Kimberly Clark purple nitrile gloves

Poly(acrylonitrile), PAN

Carbon disulfide a

2,4,7,9-Tetramethyl-5-decyn-4,7-diol (non-ionic surfactant)

CS2 is a common solvent used in the manufacture of plastics and resins. As a reducible sulfide compound, CS2 is reported to be moderately reactive to silver [1]. However, given the extremely low level detected, the Oddy test result was predicted as a temporary rating

T

T/P

Sintra (3A)

Rigid poly(vinyl chloride), PVC

2-Ethyl-1-hexanol

Chlorodecane

2-Ethylhexyl thioglycolate

Thioglycolate is a product of the mercaptotin heat stabilizers commonly added to rigid PVC. Although unstudied, thioglycolates could directly or indirectly tarnish metals. The low levels and low volatility led to a prediction of temporary

T

F/T

Komatex (Kommerling)

Rigid poly(vinyl chloride), PVC

Methyl methacrylate

2-Ethylhexyl thioglycolate

T

T

Fuhr sealant

Polyacrylate

Triethylamine

Propylene glycol

Butyl esters of succinic acid

Organic amines are known to cause corrosion of bronze, copper, and silver [28]

F

T/P

Plexiglas

Poly(methyl methacrylate), PMMA

Methyl methacrylate (monomer)

 

P

P

Volara foam (black)

Polyethylene, PE

Various branched hydrocarbons (alkanes and alkenes)

 

P

P

PUR (ester) foam

Polyester urethane, PUR

Cyclic diester

n-Alkylmorpholines (catalysts for the fabrication process)

PUR foams are generally considered safe, but the alkylmorpholines can form crystals on objects during storage [10], even though they would not corrode metal coupons

P

P

Clean seal adhesive teardrop gasket

Silicone rubber

Chlorobenzene

Siloxane compounds present

 

P

T/P

Styrene foamboard

Polystyrene, PS

Styrene

 

P

P

Fome-Cor with zeolites

Polystyrene, PS

Styrene

Benzene

Ethylbenzene

 

P

T/P

  1. Compounds in bold are thought to be dangerous for metals relevant to museum objects
  2. aCryo-trapping was employed to retain and observe this compound
  3. bThe Oddy test jar for Agateen exploded after only a few days in the oven. All coupons contained within were highly corroded and blue copper nitrate was detected by FTIR spectroscopy on the copper coupon