Skip to main content

Table 2 Advantages and disadvantages of the different treatment variants

From: Combining phytate treatment and nanocellulose stabilization for mitigating iron gall ink damage in historic papers

 

Advantages

Disadvantages

Variant 1

Shorter treatment time

Only a small amount of complexing agent is applied Complexing agents may remain in the fibre network/on the sample

Variant 2

An alkaline reserve may be deposited within the CNF layer

Shorter treatment time

Only a small amount of calcium hydrogencarbonate solution is applied   sufficient deacidification?

Variant 3

Only minor changes compared to the standard treatment

CNF and gelatine combine to form a surface layer which may get sticky at increased humidity

Variant 4

Standard treatment is applied

Final mechanical stabilization before drying

 

Variant 5

Standard treatment is applied

Pre-stabilization of the mechanically damaged objects

If applicable, protection against mechanical forces during bath treatment

Washing after CNF application   does washing out free iron ions entail an increased risk of migration?

Fibrillated nanocellulose may be partially washed out