SCALE | GALLDS indicators | The Proposed Survey Items | Resilience Proxies that Measure | Proposed Tangible and Intangible Indicators to Consider | References | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Factors Behind the Resilience in the Bazaar Area | Institutional/Management (Intangible) | Governance | -Presence of tradesmen union or Guilds in the bazaar area -Membership to Guilds or tradesmen union -The Waqf plays an important role in the bazaar area -Conservation, renewal and restoration are done by the Waqf -Conservation, renewal and restoration are done by the tradesman or Guilds | Adaptive Co-management | - Ability to reorganize - Adaptive co-management - Institutional and cultural diversity - Multilevel flexible governance - Renewel and recovery capacity | [21] [90] [87] [93] [94] [93] | |||
Spatial-Structural (Morphological) (Tangible) | Adaptability | -Total activity period -Activity period in the sector -Period spent in the shop -Changes made in the shop -Kind of changes made in the shop -Previous activity in this shop -Kind of building in which the shop is located | Adaptive Capacity | -Flexibility - Spatial and functional adaptability - Spatial Adaptive Reuse | [89] [95] [81] [63] [59] | ||||
Learning From The Past | - Type of alternative routes-streets leading to the shop - Number of alternative routes-streets leading to the shop - Presence of another branch of the shop - Location of the branch if exists | Redundancy | -Degree of internal variability, as well as functional duplication Multiplicity of: -Main routes -Main urban support services | [96] [42] [97] | |||||
Long-Term Perspectives | -The area is sufficiently accessible by public transport -Easy arrival of goods to the shop -The proximity to public transport stations increases my business | Connectivity-Accessibility | -Spatial communications in terms of the level of integrity and continuity of roads Richness of: -Accessibility -hierarchy -Urban complexity | [42] [98] [99] [100] [41] [29] | |||||
Diversity | -Type of activity - Factors that threaten the activity - Factors that threaten the bazaar area | Land Use Diversity | Rich spatial distribution, Diversity of: -Busnissess -Institutions -Functions -Land use -Forms | [101] [30] [102] [29] [103] [104] | |||||
Social-Behavioural (Intangible) | Self-Organization | -Birthplace of trader - Age of trader - Ownership status - Lodger status - Partnership type - Number of generations in the sector - There is a strong relationship between tradesmen of same street - Competition and similar activities reducethe business | -Sense of Belonging -Sense of Solidarity -Equity | Social attachment: -Sens of place, -Identity - Viable social relationships, -Passing on professions between generations | [105] [106] [92] [107] [108] [109] |