A model approach for post evaluation of adaptive reuse of architectural heritage: a case study of Beijing central axis historical buildings

Zhang, Yan; Zhang, Qi

doi:10.1186/s40494-023-00902-x

Heritage Science

Table 1 Relevant research content and factors extraction

From: A model approach for post evaluation of adaptive reuse of architectural heritage: a case study of Beijing central axis historical buildings

Relevant research study	Content description	Factors	Index	Target classification
Kincaid [42], Mason and Avrami [43], Brandenburg [44], Guy and McLendon [45], Engel [46] and Dan et al. [47]	The location of a building in a city or area	u 1 Location	B1 Physical condition	A1 Existing fabric
	Facade style and details	u 2 Facade features
	Main materials of facade and structure	u 3 Material
	Structural bearing mode	u4 Structure system
	Special construction technology	u5 Construction techniques
Bullen and Love [48], Cantacuzino [49], Smith [50] and Douglas [51]	All previous functions	u6 Original function	B2 Function
	Functions being used now	u 7 New function
	Sub functions have been added to the previous functions without completely changing the original functions	u 8 Adding some sub-function
Merlino [52], Plevoets and Van Cleempoel [53], Pendlebury et al. [54]	The original material is not applicable to the current function, and the new material replaces the original material	u 9 New materials	B3 Update part
	Application of new technology in historical buildings	u10 New techniques
	New decoration for new functions	u11 New decoration
Ching [55], Schittich [56] and Radwan [57]	Main function space	u12 Main space	B4 Spatial form	A2 Spatial character
	Space for traffic	u13 Traffic space
	Connection and combination of spaces	u14 Spatial organization
	Space outside the building	u15 Outdoor space
	Size of space	u16 Spatial scale	B5 Space quality
	Landscape elements in space	u17 Landscape factor	B5 Space quality
Delafons and Delafons [58], Barker and Marano [59] and Pickard [60]	International general charters on reuse	u18 International charters	B6 Related policy	A3 Policy and value
	Local requirements for building reuse	u19 Local principles
	Local laws on building reuse	u20 Local laws
Ruskin [61] and Stubbs [62]	Cultural value and information of history	u21 Historical culture and value	B7 Heritage value
Loulanski [63] and Throsby [64]	Expenditure on reuse	u22 Decoration cost	B8 Economic value
Loulanski [63] and Throsby [64]	Source of income for reuse	u23 Reuse income	B8 Economic value
Feilden [65] and Larkham [66]	Memory and intangible cultural heritage	u24 Memory information	B9 Memorial Value
Feilden [65] and Larkham [66]	Special customs	u25 Cultural content	B9 Memorial Value

Back to article page