Change is permanent: thoughts on the fading of cochineal-based watercolor pigments
© The Author(s) 2017
Received: 27 February 2017
Accepted: 25 May 2017
Published: 26 July 2017
Color change in artworks has been commented on for centuries. Fading of watercolor pigments is a notable alteration. Pigments based on carminic acid are among those particularly prone to color loss, but the mechanism and factors are not well understood.
KeywordsCarminic acid Carmine Cochineal Lake pigments Fading Anthraquinone
Color change in artworks has been commented on for centuries; today our awareness of its occurrence and our understanding of the complexity of the chemistry is increasing. Long ago, Cennino Cennini wrote in c. 1400 on the alteration of color, giving examples of inherent vice, problems due to incompatibility of materials, and the effects of methods of preparation of pigments causing color change in works of art. He noted that red lead and orpiment turn black in air; he provided a list of pigments that ought not be used in fresco, and he commented that red lakes are unstable, noting that the method used for preparation of the pigments has a large effect on the stability of the product: specifically, he said that the lake pigment made from cloth shearings does not last at all compared to that made directly from the resin, due to the presence of alum , an observation which will be discussed further.
There are multiple reasons to investigate the reactivity of artists’ materials; for example, knowing what was used helps us appreciate the artistic intent, and understanding the chemistry of change allows acceptance of inevitable alteration, but also helps us to mitigate change due to factors we can control—such as storage and exhibition conditions, and adverse reactions to specific treatments. Although fading of fugitive colorants, for example, turnsole, eosine, or tartrazine, is notable and well known to conservators, other changes may be slow or be initiated by a specific chemical event, such as a change in water content or pH, and therefore the cause is less immediately recognizable. Investigating and understanding immediate or incipient change requires research into the fast and slow chemical reactions of inorganic and organic compounds, their response to light, humidity and pollutants, crystallographic changes, and also into the interactions among the chemical constituents of paint. Without knowledge of the original pigment’s color we cannot be sure if we are observing change, we are lacking information needed to understand the artist’s original intent, and it is challenging to specify suitable display conditions and/or treatment options.
Recent studies have taken advantage of advanced instrumental methods to characterize the products of color change of artists’ pigments and investigate their causes. The presence of pararealgar in paintings has been shown to be due to transformation of realgar on exposure to visible light , certain forms of lead chromate (apparently those prepared a specific way) are not stable in light and react with the binder, changing color and decreasing the strength of the paint film . The complexity of factors involved in the color changes of inorganic pigments such as red lead [4, 5], cadmium yellow , and vermilion [7–9]—long observed—have been investigated. These pigments can be synthesized using different methods or have variations in their formulation that give products with different hues and significantly different reactivity. The reactions between pigments and binding media are becoming better understood: the example of metal soap formation, which changes the opacity of paint and therefore its effect on color is notable , the change in color of verdigris has been recorded [11–13].
This paper presents results that test Cennini’s observation on the relative reactivity of an alum-mordanted anthraquinone pigment (cochineal) compared to the uncomplexed compound, and examines the role of the pH of the paper substrate in the relative rate of fading of cochineal-based watercolor pigments made using three nineteenth-century recipes.
Pigments were prepared based on recipes in a late nineteenth century book on pigment manufacture . Dried cochineal insects (Colpa Apx Grupo Inca, Peru (batch SO181-13/01 21/12/2001)) as received were finely ground using a pigment mill to give a dark red powder that was used in all subsequent experiments. Water was purified using a Millipore RO system (18 MΩ-cm). Potassium bitartrate (KC4H5O6, McCormicks) and potassium aluminium sulphate (alum, KAl(SO4)2·12H2O, 98%, Aldrich Chemical Co.) were used as received. Tin(IV) chloride was prepared by dissolving tin (Sn, Analytical Reagent grade, Mallinckrodt) in 6 M hydrochloric acid (Fisher Scientific). The resultant solution was decanted off excess metallic tin and left exposed to air for several days prior to use. All pigments were allowed to precipitate, then filtered, rinsed in a filter funnel, dried and then reground in water. Sefar Yellow Swiss Nitex mesh was used in the Buchner funnel and in lieu of paper filters which clogged easily.
Unlaked carmine (CA)
Powdered cochineal insects (80 g) were placed in a nylon bag and suspended in 500 mL water and boiled for 1 h. The deeply colored aqueous extract was covered with Parafilm and allowed to sit for 2 days. Following this, KC4H5O6 (2.5 g) was added, stirred and solid pigment allowed to settle out over several days. The supernatant was decanted off and the pigment that had settled was allowed to dry, then washed in a filter funnel and reground in minimum water using a muller and again allowed to dry.
Alum-laked pigment (CA-Al)
The solid obtained above was dissolved in hot water and solid alum added. The mixture was allowed to cool and the aluminium complex precipitated. The supernatant was decanted off and the product allowed to dry then washed in a Buchner filter, then ground with water and allowed to dry.
Tin-laked pigment (CA-Sn)
The tin lake was prepared analogously with tin chloride solution being added dropwise to the solution of carmine to give a bright red precipitate that was washed in a Buchner filter funnel, dried, reground in water and allowed to dry.
Whatman qualitative filter paper No. 3 (c. 27 cm diameter) with no further treatment was used as a support with a near neutral pH. For alkaline papers, either Whatman qualitative filter paper No. 3 was immersed in calcium hydroxide solution (pH c. 13) for 15 min and air dried, or commercially-obtained buffered acid-free tissue paper was used. For experiments involving unlaked carmine and tin-laked carmine only the tissue paper was used. An acidic paper was prepared by brushing Whatman qualitative filter paper No. 3 with a traditional gelatin/alum paper sizing solution prepared using a 2.5% w/vol aqueous solution of gelatin mixed with alum in 100:1 wt% ratio [22, 23] and dried in air. The surface pH was measured using an Oakton Phelect flat electrode on the wetted surface of the papers to provide a general sense of the pH.
Watercolor paints were made by mixing the dried and reground pigment into a 2% w/vol solution of gum Arabic. The paint was applied onto large sheets of the paper substrates (diameter c. 27 cm) using a spray gun. A very dilute solution or suspension was used to avoid clogging the spray gun, and the color was built up using many sweeping passes, each with little pigment, until the maximum reflectance in the visible region was 34–45% following the ASTM 5067-93 method (Standard Specification for Artists’ Watercolor Paints). The application was uniform, variations in measured color over the sheets were within ±0.4 ΔE units.
In the samples not exposed to light, color change was calculated relative to the first measurement, and the average of five values was calculated. Color change in exposed samples was calculated with respect to the average measured L*a*b* of the unexposed swatches. The value of ΔE in each set was almost always smaller than 1, and the average of six measurements was less than 1. Values from two replicates of each preparation were measured. The greatest variation was in the paint-outs of the tin-complexed samples, perhaps due to the grainier paint.
Samples were light-aged in an Atlas Ci65A weatherometer using simulated daylight through plate glass at 75,000 lx (the equivalent of a very bright sunny day). Paper swatches affixed to aluminum plates using metal clips were removed at time intervals ranging from 1 to 70 h (by which time one sample had bleached completely) and the color measured. Two swatches of each sample were used. Temperature and RH were not controlled.
Cennini’s observations regarding the relative stability of red lakes were likely made about the pigments prepared from lac or kermes, that contain laccaic acid (7-acetyl-6-ethyl-3,5,8-trihydroxy-9,10-dioxo-9,10-dihydro-1,2-anthracene dicarboxylic acid) or kermesic acid (3,5,6,8-tetrahydroxy-1-methyl-9,10-dioxo-9,10-dihydroanthracene-2-carboxylic acid), which are chemically related to carminic acid, the main component in the cochineal colors. These molecules are members of the chemical class of anthraquinones, as are alizarin, purpurin, and pseudopurpurin, which are among the molecules extracted from various roots and found in preparations of the colorant madder. Owing to their chemical similarity, in the following discussion we will assume that measurements of one member of the anthraquinone class are relevant, even if not completely similar, to understanding the chemistry of all members of the class.
The results presented here conform to Cennini’s observation about red lakes prepared from alum-mordanted clothlets being less stable than those made directly from the unmordanted species. A similar observation had been made by Saunders and Kirby  who found that watercolors made using uncomplexed carminic acid were more stable than either the aluminium- or tin-complexed colorants. They found that the presence of Ca2+ in the formulation destabilized the aluminium complex. Analogous results have been observed for dyed fibers; for example, Gupta et al.  comparing the effect of various mordants and mordanting methods on the lightfastness of purpurin on nylon, found that while mordanting with copper or iron improved lightfastness, using aluminium, and to some extent tin, decreased the relative lightfastness of the dye compared to the unmordanted dye. Similar results were obtained for wool, and the procedures used for dyeing influence stability on wool as well as on nylon [27, 28]. Alum and tin mordants for yellow dyes on wool gave the least stable colors . Our experiments show that the situation is complex, and that the pH of a paper substrate contributes to the comparative instability of an anthraquinone dye or pigment in watercolor paint whether mordanted (i.e., complexed) or not.
Most studies of the chemistry of anthraquinones have been carried out in solution on uncomplexed species, though there has been work on a number of metal–ligand complexes in the solid state that were aimed to assist preservation studies and link to solution chemistry [30, 31]. Despite considerable research, the mechanisms and parameters affecting fading have not been fully elucidated, and in fact there are directly contradictory statements in the literature, as well as assertions that are not universally applicable, such as relationships between intensity of luminescence and photostability, and that deprotonated species are more light stable. These conflicting interpretations appear to be because a large number of factors contribute to change and loss of color of anthraquinone compounds, including pH, the presence of reducing/oxidizing agents, the concentration of oxygen, the wavelength used for photochemical reactions, and in the condensed phase, RH, among others. Control of all these parameters at once is difficult and rarely seen or achievable. It is also apparent that there are oxidative and non-oxidative pathways to colorless compounds, and both thermal and photochemical processes operate.
Role of the binding medium
As shown here and in other work, the chemical environment affects the stability of the cochineal pigments and dyes on objects. Anthraquinones have well-known antioxidant effects, even if they are not always potent . Anthraquinone is used in the delignification of wood pulp for paper-making where its effect is thought to occur by electron transfer to a lignin molecule . The antioxidant properties of anthraquinones are evident from the slow drying of oil paints that comprise red lakes. A few studies on the fading of this class of pigment in watercolor paints have been undertaken, and effects of the binding medium and the paper substrate on reactivity of the pigments have been observed [43, 44]. In a study of the madder watercolors, increased degradation of paper was noted when iron-containing madder paints were used  suggesting redox chemistry involving electron transfer; analogously, the paper support has been shown to be involved in photo-fading of the redox-active pigment Prussian blue . These observations indicate more work will need to be done to investigate the activity of lake pigments in the presence of binders and supports to understand their mutual influence. The work reported here suggests that understanding the parameters that are the major influences on the stability of lakes in paint is complex, and determining how the redox chemistry of anthraquinones is affected by its environment, notably from this study the role of the pH of paper, requires further examination.
Chemical alteration that leads to changes in color needs to be distinguished from artists’ intentional use of novel or atypical materials or mixtures. Our increasingly sophisticated methods for chemical analysis can be applied to understanding color use and unforeseen color change in artifacts. Knowing the original materials used in ancient color worlds gives us an understanding of their aesthetics, technology and trade routes, but our conclusions must be tempered through understanding unintentional change in chemistry and color.
For the red lake pigments on paper, color loss on exposure to light and its mitigation are the largest concern for conservation; however, increased sensitivity to light or color changes possibly occurring due to changing pH during treatments are also important to keep in mind. Empirical observations regarding stability are clearly limited: however, when dealing with comparatively slow reactions that can be documented visually in works of art, they offer insight into anticipating incipient change, and help focus experimental research onto fruitful paths along which interesting chemical processes that are associated with ongoing color change in art can be investigated. The factors involved are numerous, and the chemistry of the entire system that forms the artwork is implicated in change, as demonstrated in this work by the role of pH of the substrate on different forms of cochineal-based colorants. Anecdotal evidence from conservators and artists may help focus our work on the variables most important for preservation of cultural heritage.
BHB and YS conceived and designed the study. BHB prepared the lake pigments and wrote the paper. YS prepared the paper samples, the paint samples, undertook the aging studies, and performed the color measurements. The work was undertaken at NGA. Both authors read and approved the final manuscript.
We are grateful to Michael R. Palmer for assistance in the aging studies and Michelle Stein for photography of the paint sample swatches.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
- Cennini C. The Craftsman's Handbook 'Il Libro dell’Arte'. New York: Dover; 1954. p. 26.Google Scholar
- Corbeil MC, Helwig K. An occurrence of pararealgar as an original or altered artists’ pigment. Stud Conserv. 1995;40:133–8. doi:10.2307/1506513.Google Scholar
- Monico L, Janssens K, Hendriks E, Vanmeert F, Snickt G, Cotte M, et al. Evidence for degradation of the chrome yellows in van Gogh’s sunflowers: a study using noninvasive in situ methods and synchrotron radiation-based X-ray techniques. Ang Chem Int Edit. 2015. doi:10.1002/anie.201505840.Google Scholar
- Aze S, Vallet JM, Detalle V, Grauby O, Baronnet A. Chromatic alterations of red lead pigments in artworks: a review. Phase Transit. 2008;81(2–3):145–54. doi:10.1080/01411590701514326.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Zhao Y, Tang Y, Tong T, Sun Z, Yu Z, Zhu Y, et al. Red lead degradation: monitoring of color change over time. New J Chem. 2016;40(4):3686–92. doi:10.1039/C5NJ02426A.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Pouyet E, Cotte M, Fayard B, Salomé M, Meirer F, Mehta A, et al. 2D X-ray and FTIR micro-analysis of the degradation of cadmium yellow pigment in paintings of Henri Matisse. Appl Phys A. 2015;121(3):967–80. doi:10.1007/s00339-015-9239-4.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Spring M, Grout R. The blackening of vermilion: an analytical study of the process in paintings. Natl Gallery Tech Bull. 2002;23:50–61.Google Scholar
- Keune K, Boon JJ. Analytical imaging studies clarifying the process of the darkening of vermilion in paintings. Anal Chem. 2005;77(15):4742–50. doi:10.1021/ac048158f.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hogan C, Da Pieve F. Colour degradation of artworks: an ab initio approach to X-ray, electronic and optical spectroscopy analyses of vermilion photodarkening. J Anal At Spectrom. 2015;30(3):588–98. doi:10.1039/C4JA00327F.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Noble P, van Loon A, Boon JJ. Chemical changes in old master paintings II: darkening due to increased transparency and metal soap formation. In: Verger I, editor. ICOM-CC 14th triennial meeting preprints. London: James and James; 2005. p. 496–503.Google Scholar
- van den Berg KJ, Van Eikema Hommes MH, Groen KM, Boon JJ, Berrie BH. On copper green glazes in paintings. In: Goupy J, Mohen JP, editors. Art et chemie, la couleur. Paris: CNRS; 2000. p. 18–21.Google Scholar
- Kühn H. Verdigris and copper resinate. In: Roy A, editor. Artists’ pigments: a handbook of their history and characteristics. Washington, DC: National Gallery of Art and Archetype; 2012.Google Scholar
- De la Roja JM, San Andrés M, Cubino NS, Santos-Gómez S. Variations in the colorimetric characteristics of verdigris pictorial films depending on the process used to produce the pigment and the type of binding agent used in applying it. Color Res Appl. 2007;32(5):414–23. doi:10.1002/col.20311.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Brommelle NS. The Russell and Abney report on the action of light on water colours. Stud Conserv. 1964;9(4):140–52. doi:10.2307/1505213.Google Scholar
- Beltran VL, Druzik J, Maekawa S. Large-scale assessment of light-induced color change in air and anoxic environments. Stud Conserv. 2012;57(1):42–57.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lerwill A, Townsend JH, Thomas J, Hackney S, Caspers C, Liang H. Photochemical colour change for traditional watercolour pigments in low oxygen levels. Stud Conserv. 2015;60(1):15–32.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Cardon D. Natural dyes: sources, tradition, technology and science. London: Archetype; 2007.Google Scholar
- Schweppe H, Roosen-Runge H. Carmine. In: Feller RL, editor. Artists pigments: a handbook of their history and characteristics. Washington, DC: National Gallery of Art; 1986. p. 255–83.Google Scholar
- Neri A. The art of glass. Sheffield: Society of Glass Technology; 2001. p. 408.Google Scholar
- Church AH. The chemistry of paints and painting. London: Seeley and Co., Ltd.; 1890. p. 208.Google Scholar
- Bersch J. The manufacture of mineral and lake pigments. London: Scott, Greenwood; 1901. p. 358-60.Google Scholar
- Brückle I. The role of alum in historical papermaking. Abbey Newslett. 1993;17(4). http://cool.conservation-us.org/byorg/abbey/an/an17/an17-4/an17-407.html.
- Barrett T. 4.2 Conservation paper production. Pap Conserv. 1989;13(1):73–5. doi:10.1080/03094227.1989.9638372.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Joel A, Indictor N, Hanlan JF, Baer NS. The measurement and significance of pH in paper conservation. Bull Am Gr Int Inst Conserv Hist Artist Works. 1972;12(2):119–25. doi:10.2307/3179136.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Saunders D, Kirby J. Light-induced colour changes in red and yellow lake pigments. Natl Gallery Tech Bull. 1994;15:79–97.Google Scholar
- Gupta D, Gulrajani ML, Kumari S. Light fastness of naturally occurring anthraquinone dyes on nylon. Coloration Technology. 2004;120(5):205-12. doi:10.1111/j.1478-4408.2004.tb00119.x.Google Scholar
- Manhita A, Ferreira V, Vargas H, Ribeiro I, Candeias A, Teixeira D, et al. Enlightening the influence of mordant, dyeing technique and photodegradation on the colour hue of textiles dyed with madder—a chromatographic and spectrometric approach. Microchem J. 2011;98(1):82–90. doi:10.1016/j.microc.2010.12.002.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Clementi C, Nowik W, Romani A, Cibin F, Favaro G. A spectrometric and chromatographic approach to the study of ageing of madder (Rubia tinctorum L) dyestuff on wool. Anal Chim Acta. 2007;596(1):46–54. doi:10.1016/j.aca.2007.05.036.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Crews PC. The influence of mordant on the lightfastness of yellow natural dyes. J Am Inst Conserv. 1982;21(2):43–58.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Rader Bowers LM, Schmidtke Sobeck SJ. Impact of medium and ambient environment on the photodegradation of carmine in solution and paints. Dyes Pigm. 2016;127:18–24. doi:10.1016/j.dyepig.2015.12.012.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Grazia C, Clementi C, Miliani C, Romani A. Photophysical properties of alizarin and purpurin Al(III) complexes in solution and in solid state. Photochem Photobiol Sci. 2011;10(7):1249–54. doi:10.1039/C1PP05039G.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Stapelfeldt H, Jun H, Skibsted LH. Fluorescence properties of carminic acid in relation to aggregation, complex formation and oxygen activation in aqueous food models. Food Chem. 1993;48(1):1–11. doi:10.1016/0308-8146(93)90213-y.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kunkely H, Vogler A. Absorption and luminescence spectra of cochineal. Inorg Chem Commun. 2011;14(7):1153–5. doi:10.1016/j.inoche.2011.04.011.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Comini LR, Moran Vieyra FE, Mignone RA, Paez PL, Laura Mugas M, Konigheim BS, et al. Parietin: an efficient photo-screening pigment in vivo with good photosensitizing and photodynamic antibacterial effects in vitro. Photochem Photobiol Sci. 2017;16(2):201–10. doi:10.1039/C6PP00334F.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Tan JA, Garakyaraghi S, Tagami KA, Frano KA, Crockett HM, Ogata AF, et al. Contributions from excited-state proton and electron transfer to the blinking and photobleaching dynamics of alizarin and purpurin. J Phys Chem C. 2017;121(1):97–106. doi:10.1021/acs.jpcc.6b09818.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Morales KM, Berrie BH. A note on characterization of the cochineal dyestuff on wool using microspectrophotometry. e-Preserv Sci. 2015;12:8–14.Google Scholar
- Rowley DA, Cooper JC. Solution equilibria of alizarin red S with Al(III) and Ni(III). Inorg Chim Acta. 1988;147:257–9.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Atabey H, Sari H, Al-Obaidi FN. Protonation equilibria of carminic acid and stability constants of its complexes with some divalent metal ions in aqueous solution. J Sol Chem. 2012;41(5):793–803. doi:10.1007/s10953-012-9830-7.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- de Sousa AT, Bessler KE, Lemos SS, Ellena J, Gatto CC. Organotin complexes of alizarin and purpurin. Z Anorg Allg Chem. 2009;635(1):106–11. doi:10.1002/zaac.200800313.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Fain VY, Zaitsev BE, Ryabov MA. Tautomerism of metal complexes with carminic acid. Russ J Coord Chem. 2008;34(4):310–4. doi:10.1134/s1070328408040118.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ruifa J, Hongzheng B, Yin B, Xiuhua L. Theoretical study on the antioxidant activity of alizarin, purpurin, and pseudopurpurin. In: Limin Angela L, Dongqing W, Yixue L, editors. Interdisciplinary research and applications in bioinformatics, computational biology, and environmental sciences. Hershey: IGI Global; 2011. p. 130–40.Google Scholar
- Hocking M, Bolker H, Fleming B. An investigation of anthraquinone-catalysed alkaline pulping via component modeling and electron spin resonance experiments. Can J Chem. 1980;58(18):1983–92. doi:10.1139/v80-315.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Thomas J, Townsend JH, Hackney S, Strlič M. A chemiluminescence study of madder lakes on paper. Polym Degrad Stab. 2010;95(12):2343–9. doi:10.1016/j.polymdegradstab.2010.08.024.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Claro A, Melo MJ, Schäfer S, Seixas de Melo JS, Pina F, van den Berg KJ, et al. The use of microspectrofluorimetry for the characterization of lake pigments. Talanta. 2008;74:922–9. doi:10.1016/j.talanta.2007.07.036.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gervais C, Languille M-A, Reguer S, Gillet M, Pelletier S, Garnier C, et al. Why does Prussian blue fade? Understanding the role(s) of the substrate. J Anal At Spectrom. 2013;28(10):1600–9. doi:10.1039/C3JA50025J.View ArticleGoogle Scholar